Buying guide

Pizza Stones & Steels

Our pick

Baking Steel Original

Choose the Baking Steel Original for pizza in a home oven with room for its 16 by 14 inch slab.1

Compare the alternatives

Why this one

  • Its steel surface favors strong heat transfer to pizza dough, with a compact 16 by 14 inch footprint compared with the 20.1 by 15 inch Bread Steel Duo.123

Before you buy: The Original weighs 16 lb; choose a weight you can lift and store comfortably.2

The alternatives

Other contenders

  • Baking Steel Pro

    Choose the Pro if you want a square 16 by 16 inch steel surface and can lift and store its 27 lb weight; it arrives pre-seasoned.4

  • Brød & Taylor Bread Steel Duo

    Choose the Bread Steel Duo when you want a wider baking surface and your oven has room for 20.1 by 15 inches; it weighs 12.26 lb and arrives pre-seasoned.36

  • Old Stone Glazed Pizza Stone

    Choose the Old Stone 14 by 16 inch glazed stone if you prefer cordierite and a lighter slab to handle; it weighs about 8.7 lb.578

Buying advice

  • Measure your oven rack and leave the clearance required by the maker before choosing a slab.13

Compare the options

4 products

Compare models side by side

Models in this comparison

Every specification for these products
SpecificationBaking Steel OriginalBaking Steel ProBrød & Taylor Bread Steel DuoOld Stone Glazed Pizza Stone
MaterialSteel2Steel4Steel2Cordierite ceramic5
Thickness≈0.25 in (6.35 mm)10.375 in40.15 in30.6 in8
Weight16 lb227 lb412.26 lb3≈8.68 lb (138.9 oz)8
Length16 in116 in420.1 in314 in7
Seasoning—Pre seasoned4Pre seasoned6—

Compare features

Reset requirements

4 products

How they compare

SpecificationOur pickBaking Steel OriginalBaking Steel ProBrød & Taylor Bread Steel DuoOld Stone Glazed Pizza Stone
Buy
MaterialSteel2Steel4Steel2Cordierite ceramic5
Thickness≈0.25 in (6.35 mm)10.375 in40.15 in30.6 in8
Weight16 lb227 lb412.26 lb3≈8.68 lb (138.9 oz)8
Length16 in116 in420.1 in314 in7
Seasoning—Pre seasoned4Pre seasoned6—

Sources

  1. www.bakingsteel.com
  2. www.americastestkitchen.com
  3. brodandtaylor.com
  4. bakingsteel.com
  5. kitchensupply.com
  6. www.desertcart.in
  7. www.chefsupplies.ca
  8. support.kitchensupply.com