Buying guide
Solid Grill Fire Starters
Our pick
Meeco's Red Devil SureStart Firelighting Squares
Choose Meeco’s Red Devil SureStart Firelighting Squares for regular charcoal grilling if you prefer a wood-fiber starter.1
Why this one
The alternatives
Other contenders
Rutland Safe Lite Fire Starter Squares Box of 24 Squares
Choose Rutland’s 24-square box for a smaller supply made from recycled wood chips, paper fiber and wax. Keep it dry: Bob Vila’s testers could not light the squares straight after removing them from a glass of water.34
For occasional cooking or trying a starter before a bulk box
A small pack suits occasional grilling or trying a starter before buying a bulk box.5 Choose Weber Lighter Cubes in the 24-piece pack; America’s Test Kitchen found no off-flavors in its test.25 After a two-hour water bath, America’s Test Kitchen could not light the starters immediately; they lit after being blotted dry with paper towels.2
Compare the options
4 products
Compare models side by side
Choose two or three products to compare.
Models in this comparison




Every specification for these products
| Specification | Meeco's Red Devil SureStart Firelighting Squares | Rutland Safe Lite Fire Starter Squares Box of 24 Squares | Rutland Safe Lite Fire Starter Squares Bulk Box of 144 Squares | Weber Lighter Cubes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pieces per pack | 144 pieces1 | 24 pieces3 | 144 pieces3 | 24 pieces5 |
| Lights when wet | Yes1 | Yes6 | Yes3 | Yes5 |
| No taste or smell on food | Yes (Test method: Grill flank steak over each bed of coals and taste for off-flavors)2 | Yes6 | Yes (Test method: Grill flank steak and zucchini over each bed of coals and taste for off-flavors)2 | Yes (Test method: Grill flank steak over each bed of coals and taste for off-flavors)2 |
| Time to ignite | — | — | 9.4 s (Test method: Light chimney starters filled with briquettes, using the lowest number of units recommended by each manufacturer and timing how long it takes for the starters to ignite)2 | — |
| Made from | compressed wood fiber and wax1 | compressed recycled wood chips, paper fiber, and wax3 | compressed recycled wood chips, paper fiber, and wax3 | Paraffin wax2 |
How they compare
| Specification | Our pickMeeco's Red Devil SureStart Firelighting Squares | Rutland Safe Lite Fire Starter Squares Box of 24 Squares | Rutland Safe Lite Fire Starter Squares Bulk Box of 144 Squares | Weber Lighter Cubes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buy | ||||
| Pieces per pack | 144 pieces1 | 24 pieces3 | 144 pieces3 | 24 pieces5 |
| Lights when wet | Yes1 | Yes6 | Yes3 | Yes5 |
| No taste or smell on food | Yes (Test method: Grill flank steak over each bed of coals and taste for off-flavors)2 | Yes6 | Yes (Test method: Grill flank steak and zucchini over each bed of coals and taste for off-flavors)2 | Yes (Test method: Grill flank steak over each bed of coals and taste for off-flavors)2 |
| Time to ignite | — | — | 9.4 s (Test method: Light chimney starters filled with briquettes, using the lowest number of units recommended by each manufacturer and timing how long it takes for the starters to ignite)2 | — |
| Made from | compressed wood fiber and wax1 | compressed recycled wood chips, paper fiber, and wax3 | compressed recycled wood chips, paper fiber, and wax3 | Paraffin wax2 |