Buying guide

Solid Grill Fire Starters

Our pick

Meeco's Red Devil SureStart Firelighting Squares

Choose Meeco’s Red Devil SureStart Firelighting Squares for regular charcoal grilling if you prefer a wood-fiber starter.1

Compare the alternatives

Why this one

  • SureStart uses compressed wood fiber and wax, so it suits buyers who prefer fiber-based squares.1
  • America’s Test Kitchen found no off-flavors when grilling flank steak over coals lit with SureStart.2

The alternatives

Other contenders

For occasional cooking or trying a starter before a bulk box

A small pack suits occasional grilling or trying a starter before buying a bulk box.5 Choose Weber Lighter Cubes in the 24-piece pack; America’s Test Kitchen found no off-flavors in its test.25 After a two-hour water bath, America’s Test Kitchen could not light the starters immediately; they lit after being blotted dry with paper towels.2

Compare the options

4 products

Compare models side by side

Models in this comparison

Every specification for these products
SpecificationMeeco's Red Devil SureStart Firelighting SquaresRutland Safe Lite Fire Starter Squares Box of 24 SquaresRutland Safe Lite Fire Starter Squares Bulk Box of 144 SquaresWeber Lighter Cubes
Pieces per pack144 pieces124 pieces3144 pieces324 pieces5
Lights when wetYes1Yes6Yes3Yes5
No taste or smell on foodYes (Test method: Grill flank steak over each bed of coals and taste for off-flavors)2Yes6Yes (Test method: Grill flank steak and zucchini over each bed of coals and taste for off-flavors)2Yes (Test method: Grill flank steak over each bed of coals and taste for off-flavors)2
Time to ignite——9.4 s (Test method: Light chimney starters filled with briquettes, using the lowest number of units recommended by each manufacturer and timing how long it takes for the starters to ignite)2—
Made fromcompressed wood fiber and wax1compressed recycled wood chips, paper fiber, and wax3compressed recycled wood chips, paper fiber, and wax3Paraffin wax2

How they compare

SpecificationOur pickMeeco's Red Devil SureStart Firelighting SquaresRutland Safe Lite Fire Starter Squares Box of 24 SquaresRutland Safe Lite Fire Starter Squares Bulk Box of 144 SquaresWeber Lighter Cubes
Buy
Pieces per pack144 pieces124 pieces3144 pieces324 pieces5
Lights when wetYes1Yes6Yes3Yes5
No taste or smell on foodYes (Test method: Grill flank steak over each bed of coals and taste for off-flavors)2Yes6Yes (Test method: Grill flank steak and zucchini over each bed of coals and taste for off-flavors)2Yes (Test method: Grill flank steak over each bed of coals and taste for off-flavors)2
Time to ignite——9.4 s (Test method: Light chimney starters filled with briquettes, using the lowest number of units recommended by each manufacturer and timing how long it takes for the starters to ignite)2—
Made fromcompressed wood fiber and wax1compressed recycled wood chips, paper fiber, and wax3compressed recycled wood chips, paper fiber, and wax3Paraffin wax2

Sources

  1. www.meecomfg.com
  2. www.americastestkitchen.com
  3. rutland.com
  4. www.bobvila.com
  5. www.weber.com
  6. hardwareworld.com